Every December, the same questions come up:
Does unused PTO roll over?
Does it expire on December 31?
Do we have to pay it out when someone leaves?
The answers start with your written policy and, in some cases, your state's law.
The federal baseline
Federal law doesn't require private employers to offer paid vacation. The U.S. Department of Labor describes vacation benefits as a matter of agreement between the employer and employee. That's why your written policy matters so much.
Why your state matters
States handle PTO very differently. A few examples:
In California, earned vacation is treated like wages. It has to be paid out when someone leaves, and "use it or lose it" policies aren't allowed.
In Colorado, earned vacation also has to be paid out at separation.
In Utah, payout generally depends on your policy or agreement.
On top of that, many states and cities have paid sick leave laws with their own rules for accrual and carryover. If you have employees in more than one state, each location may have different requirements. Your state labor department's website is a good place to check.
What your PTO policy should clearly answer
How PTO is earned (and when it starts)
Whether there's a cap on how much can build up
Whether unused time carries over, and how much
Whether time expires (and whether that's allowed in your state)
What happens to unused PTO when someone leaves
How employees request time off
Your year-end PTO checklist
Share balances now. Let employees know how much time they have left while there's still time to use it.
Remind people of deadlines. If time expires or caps out, tell them in November, not on December 30.
Plan for coverage. If everyone tries to use time in the last two weeks, decide how you'll handle requests.
Put exceptions in writing. If you allow an exception this year, document it and be consistent.
Update your policy for next year. If your practice has drifted from what's written, fix it before January.
The bottom line
Clear PTO rules prevent a lot of year-end frustration for you and your team. If your policy hasn't been updated in a while, now is a great time to take a look.
This article is general information, not legal advice. PTO rules vary by state.
Sources
U.S. Department of Labor, Vacation Leave: https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/benefits-leave/vacation_leave
California Labor Code section 227.3 (vacation pay at separation): verify at https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
Colorado earned vacation payout (Nieto v. Clark's Market, Colorado Supreme Court, 2021): verify with Colorado Department of Labor and Employment
Utah Labor Commission wage claim questionnaire (PTO payout requires an agreement or policy): https://laborcommission.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/EnglishWageIntakeQ_1.pdf